---
title: "Medical aid refused? How to lodge an objection with your health insurance fund"
url: https://www.pharmacare.de/en/guide/appeal-health-insurance-decision/
description: "Health insurance fund refused a medical aid? The deadline, what goes into an objection, when court action is free of charge and who can help – step by step."
updated: 2026-11-21
language: en
---

# Medical aid refused? How to lodge an objection with your health insurance fund

If your health insurance fund refuses a medical aid or approves less than was prescribed, that does not have to be the end of the matter. Here you can read by when and how to object, what strengthens your reasons and what happens next.

## Key points

- You have one month to lodge an objection (_Widerspruch_) after you have been notified of the decision (_Bescheid_). If a correct notice of legal remedies (_Rechtsbehelfsbelehrung_) is missing, you have one year.
- An objection costs nothing. A few sentences are enough to meet the deadline; you may send your reasons later.
- You may inspect your file, including the expert opinion on which the fund bases its decision.
- If the fund sticks to its refusal, you can take legal action at the social court (_Sozialgericht_) within one month – without court fees.
- Missed the deadline? With a request for review (_Überprüfungsantrag_), the fund must re-examine even a refusal that has become final.

## First, read the decision carefully

Clarify three questions: Does the fund refuse completely, or does it only approve less? What reasons does it give? Did it obtain an expert opinion from the Medical Service (_Medizinischer Dienst_)? It may not commission any other third party to carry out the assessment (§ 33(5b) SGB V, Social Code Book V). The deadline and the address for the objection are given in the notice of legal remedies at the end of the decision.

## Deadline and form: how to lodge an objection

The Social Courts Act (_Sozialgerichtsgesetz_, SGG) provides:

> “The objection must be lodged within one month after the administrative act has been notified to the aggrieved party, in writing, in electronic form […] or by having it recorded, with the body that issued the administrative act.”
>
> § 84(1), sentence 1 SGG (our translation)

- **Start:** A decision sent by post is deemed to have been notified on the fourth day after it was posted; if it arrives later, on the day it is received (§ 37(2) SGB X). To be on the safe side, count the deadline for the objection (_Widerspruchsfrist_) from the day the letter arrived.
- **End:** If the decision is deemed notified on 10 March, the deadline expires on 10 April. If that day falls on a weekend or a public holiday, it ends on the next working day (§ 64 SGG).
- **Form:** a signed letter, a statement recorded at one of the fund’s offices, or an electronic channel that replaces the written form, for example an online form of the fund with log-in via your electronic health card (§ 36a SGB I). A simple e-mail is not enough.
- **Recipient:** the fund that made the decision. If the objection ends up with another authority or another social insurance institution, the deadline is still met (§ 84(2) SGG).

No fees or expenses are charged (§ 64(1) SGB X). To begin with, a short letter is enough: your name, insurance number, the date and reference number of the decision, the statement that you are lodging an objection, the note “reasons to follow” (_Begründung folgt_), a request to inspect the file and your signature. Send it in a way you can prove, for example by registered post with proof of delivery (_Einwurf-Einschreiben_).

## Inspecting the file

The fund must let you see the documents of your procedure insofar as you need them to assert your rights; copies are available for reasonable reimbursement of costs (§ 25 SGB X). Check what the refusal is based on – an expert opinion or the fund’s own assessment. That is where your reasons come in.

## What makes your reasons strong

The standard is set by § 33(1) SGB V: the medical aid (_Hilfsmittel_) must be necessary in the individual case to secure the success of a treatment, to prevent an impending disability or to compensate for a disability. Show why this applies to you:

- **Doctor’s statement:** Your doctor addresses the fund’s reasons and describes what would happen without the medical aid.
- **Usage log:** If the dispute is about quantity, note down for a few days how often you change pads or catheterise, and why.
- **Everyday life:** Describe specific situations; relatives or the home care service can confirm them.
- **Guideline:** For self-catheterisation in neurogenic bladder dysfunction, the clinical guideline states that “a limitation of catheter material […] for economic reasons should not take place” (our translation). More on this in the article [Learning self-catheterisation](https://www.pharmacare.de/en/guide/learning-self-catheterisation/).

## What happens after the objection

If your objection is convincing, the fund changes its decision. Otherwise you receive a written objection decision (_Widerspruchsbescheid_) with reasons, for example from an objection committee (_Widerspruchsausschuss_), with information on how to take legal action (§ 85 SGG, § 36a SGB IV).

| Step | Deadline | Legal basis |
| --- | --- | --- |
| Objection against the decision | one month after notification | § 84 SGG |
| Objection without a correct notice of legal remedies | one year | § 66 SGG |
| Legal action against the objection decision | one month after notification | § 87 SGG |
| Legal action if the objection is not dealt with | after three months at the earliest | § 88 SGG |
| Legal action if the application is not dealt with | after six months at the earliest | § 88 SGG |

### Legal action at the social court

You bring the action in writing or by having it recorded at the registry of the social court (§ 90 SGG). You do not need a lawyer there (§ 73 SGG), and insured persons do not pay court fees (§ 183 SGG). In urgent cases, the court can issue an interim order (_einstweilige Anordnung_) in advance (§ 86b SGG).

## If the fund takes too long

The fund must decide on an application within three weeks, or within five weeks if it obtains an expert opinion – or inform you in good time, giving reasons, why it is taking longer. If it does neither, the benefit is deemed approved (§ 13(3a) SGB V).

According to a ruling of the Federal Social Court (_Bundessozialgericht_) of 26 May 2020, this does not entitle you to demand delivery. However, you may obtain the medical aid yourself and claim back the costs – unless you knew, or should readily have recognised, that you are not entitled to it.

This rule does not apply to medical aids that are meant to compensate for or prevent a disability: according to the Federal Social Court (ruling of 15 March 2018), they count as medical rehabilitation, and the fund then has two months (§ 18 SGB IX). Get advice before you pay in advance.

## Missed the deadline – what now?

If you were prevented through no fault of your own, apply for reinstatement (_Wiedereinsetzung in den vorigen Stand_) within one month after the obstacle has ceased and submit the missed objection (§ 67 SGG). If the decision has already become final, a request for review remains: if the fund applied the law incorrectly or based its decision on incorrect facts, it must withdraw its decision. Benefits are then paid retroactively for up to four years (§ 44 SGB X).

## Decisions of the long-term care insurance

You object to decisions of the long-term care insurance fund (_Pflegekasse_), for example on the care level (_Pflegegrad_), in exactly the same way. You receive the assessment report with the decision unless you have objected to it being sent, and you can also request it later (§ 18c SGB XI). Compare it point by point with your everyday life. More in the article [Applying for a care level](https://www.pharmacare.de/en/guide/applying-for-a-care-level/).

## Frequently asked questions

### Can someone lodge the objection for me?

Yes, for example a relative free of charge, or a social welfare association (_Sozialverband_) of which you are a member. If asked, your representative must present a written power of attorney (§ 13 SGB X).

### Who advises me free of charge?

The Independent Patient Advice Foundation Germany (_Stiftung Unabhängige Patientenberatung Deutschland_), free of charge on 0800 011 77 22. Social welfare associations such as the VdK advise and represent their members, including before the social courts. In difficult cases, a lawyer specialising in social law can help.

### What if I need the medical aid urgently?

Then you can apply to the social court for an interim order. If you buy the medical aid yourself after the refusal, you get the costs back if the fund refused it wrongly (§ 13(3) SGB V). Until then, however, you bear the risk.

## How PharmaCare helps

If you submit your prescription (_Rezept_) to us, we arrange approval with your health insurance fund. Send the original to PharmaCare GmbH, Raiffeisenallee 16, 82041 Oberhaching – the easiest way is with the free envelope from our [downloads (in German)](https://www.pharmacare.de/downloads/). You can send us a photo in advance via WhatsApp or Signal.

Our qualified specialists advise you on suitable products independently of any manufacturer, free of charge, Monday to Friday from 8 am to 5 pm.

[0800 74 222 73](tel:+498007422273) [WhatsApp](https://wa.me/498007422273) [Signal](https://www.pharmacare.de/signal/)

[Submit a prescription](https://www.pharmacare.de/en/prescription-service/) · [Arrange a call-back](https://upload.pharmacare.de/en/rueckruf?quelle=web)

## Sources

- Social Courts Act (Sozialgerichtsgesetz): [§ 64](https://www.gesetze-im-internet.de/sgg/__64.html), [§ 66](https://www.gesetze-im-internet.de/sgg/__66.html), [§ 67](https://www.gesetze-im-internet.de/sgg/__67.html), [§ 73](https://www.gesetze-im-internet.de/sgg/__73.html), [§ 84](https://www.gesetze-im-internet.de/sgg/__84.html), [§ 85](https://www.gesetze-im-internet.de/sgg/__85.html), [§ 86b](https://www.gesetze-im-internet.de/sgg/__86b.html), [§ 87](https://www.gesetze-im-internet.de/sgg/__87.html), [§ 88](https://www.gesetze-im-internet.de/sgg/__88.html), [§ 90](https://www.gesetze-im-internet.de/sgg/__90.html), [§ 183](https://www.gesetze-im-internet.de/sgg/__183.html), Federal Ministry of Justice (in German)
- SGB X: [§ 13](https://www.gesetze-im-internet.de/sgb_10/__13.html), [§ 25](https://www.gesetze-im-internet.de/sgb_10/__25.html), [§ 37](https://www.gesetze-im-internet.de/sgb_10/__37.html), [§ 44](https://www.gesetze-im-internet.de/sgb_10/__44.html), [§ 64](https://www.gesetze-im-internet.de/sgb_10/__64.html), Federal Ministry of Justice (in German)
- [§ 36a SGB I](https://www.gesetze-im-internet.de/sgb_1/__36a.html), [§ 36a SGB IV](https://www.gesetze-im-internet.de/sgb_4/__36a.html), [§ 13 SGB V](https://www.gesetze-im-internet.de/sgb_5/__13.html), [§ 33 SGB V](https://www.gesetze-im-internet.de/sgb_5/__33.html), [§ 18 SGB IX](https://www.gesetze-im-internet.de/sgb_9_2018/__18.html), [§ 18c SGB XI](https://www.gesetze-im-internet.de/sgb_11/__18c.html), [§ 6 Legal Services Act (Rechtsdienstleistungsgesetz)](https://www.gesetze-im-internet.de/rdg/__6.html), Federal Ministry of Justice (in German)
- Federal Social Court: [ruling of 26 May 2020, B 1 KR 9/18 R](https://www.bsg.bund.de/SharedDocs/Entscheidungen/DE/2020/2020_05_26_B_01_KR_09_18_R.html), and [ruling of 15 March 2018, B 3 KR 18/17 R](https://www.bsg.bund.de/SharedDocs/Entscheidungen/DE/2018/2018_03_15_B_03_KR_18_17_R.html) (in German)
- [S2k guideline on intermittent catheterisation in neurogenic dysfunction of the lower urinary tract](https://register.awmf.org/de/leitlinien/detail/043-048), AWMF register 043-048, version of 3 February 2026 (in German)
- [Independent Patient Advice Foundation Germany (Stiftung Unabhängige Patientenberatung Deutschland)](https://www.patientenberatung.de/) and [social law advice from the VdK](https://www.vdk.de/themen/sozialrecht/) (in German)

Note: This article gives a general overview and does not replace medical or legal advice. Your health insurance fund or long-term care insurance decides on your entitlement. The text was written with the help of artificial intelligence; all information has been checked against the sources listed. As of: 24 September 2026.

---

PharmaCare GmbH, Raiffeisenallee 16, 82041 Oberhaching, Germany · Phone 0800 74 222 73 (free within Germany, Mon–Fri 8 am–5 pm) · kundenservice@pharmacare.de · Web page: https://www.pharmacare.de/en/guide/appeal-health-insurance-decision/
