
For pads, catheters or other medical aids, you are sometimes told that you need to pay extra. Whether that is true, you can check with a few questions – based on the rules the law sets out.
Key points
- For sufficient and appropriate supplies, you only pay the statutory co-payment (Zuzahlung).
- Extra costs (Mehrkosten), often called a surcharge (Aufzahlung), are only lawful if you yourself choose a medical aid that goes beyond what is medically necessary.
- Beforehand, the supplier must advise you, document the advice, have you sign it and tell you the amount of the extra costs.
- The health insurance funds’ contracts must ensure a sufficient number of medical aids without extra costs. If the quantity is not enough, what is needed is an adjusted prescription, not a surcharge.
- In 2025, extra costs were incurred in just over 30 per cent of supplies of incontinence aids, and in just over 1 per cent of cases for ostomy articles.
Co-payment, extra costs, personal contribution: not the same thing
In everyday life, the terms are often mixed up. In its report on extra costs (Mehrkostenbericht), the National Association of Statutory Health Insurance Funds (GKV-Spitzenverband) distinguishes between:
- Co-payment: the amount set by law that adults pay towards every medical aid (Hilfsmittel) – for consumable products, currently no more than 10 euros a month. It counts towards the annual cap (Belastungsgrenze), and an exemption is possible.
- Extra costs or surcharge: costs for features or a service that you choose yourself and that go beyond what is medically necessary (§ 33(1) SGB V, Social Code Book V).
- Personal contribution (Eigenanteil): an amount for medical aids that contain or replace an everyday item, such as orthopaedic shoes.
Extra costs do not count towards the annual cap. An exemption from co-payments therefore makes no difference to them. How to apply for this exemption is explained in the article Exemption from co-payments.
What your health insurance fund owes you
The standard is set by the principle of economic efficiency (Wirtschaftlichkeitsgebot):
“The benefits must be sufficient, appropriate and economical; they must not exceed what is necessary.”
§ 12(1), sentence 1 SGB V (our translation)
The principle works in both directions: the fund does not have to pay for what goes beyond what is necessary – but it must pay for what is necessary in full. The standard is your personal situation. For absorbent incontinence aids, the list of medical aids (Hilfsmittelverzeichnis) makes clear that the number of items is not calculated solely from the amount of urine and the absorption capacity; hygiene and the care situation also count. Depending on the individual case, five or more products a day may be needed.
In addition, medical aids must at least meet the quality requirements of the list of medical aids (§ 33(1), sentence 2 SGB V). So a product without a surcharge is not automatically a poor product.
When extra costs are permitted
The rule is set out in § 33(1), sentence 9 SGB V:
“If insured persons choose medical aids or additional services that go beyond what is necessary, they must bear the extra costs and any resulting higher follow-up costs themselves.”
§ 33(1), sentence 9 SGB V (our translation)
The key word is “choose”: extra costs require that you make a choice. The National Association of Statutory Health Insurance Funds names comfort or appearance as typical reasons. If you want a product with features that are not medically necessary, you may have it – and pay the difference.
It is different if you are left with no choice at all. In their contracts with suppliers, the health insurance funds must ensure a sufficient number of medical aids without extra costs (§ 127(1) SGB V). If you are not offered such a supply, a surcharge is not a free decision.
Advice before supply is mandatory
Before delivering, the supplier must advise you. § 127(5) SGB V provides:
“Before the benefit is used, service providers must advise insured persons on which medical aids and additional services under § 33(1), sentences 1 and 5, are suitable and necessary for the specific supply situation in the individual case. Service providers must document the advice under sentence 1 in writing or electronically and have it confirmed by the signature of the insured person.”
§ 127(5), sentences 1 and 2 SGB V (our translation)
If extra costs come into question, the supplier must also inform you of their amount before you choose, and have this confirmed as well. So you can expect:
- advice before the supply begins,
- written or electronic documentation that you sign,
- information on which supply is suitable and necessary for you – that is, the one your fund covers without a surcharge,
- where there are extra costs, their amount before you decide.
If the quantity is not enough
If you are asked to pay extra because the fund will supposedly only pay for a certain number of items, keep in mind that the quantity is part of the medically necessary supply. If it is not enough, an adjusted prescription is the right way forward.
For people who catheterise because of neurogenic bladder dysfunction, the clinical guideline is clear: catheter material, the frequency of catheterisation and the amount you drink should not be limited for cost reasons, because this can harm your health. The guideline fundamentally rejects attempts by health insurance funds to limit the number of catheters, for example through standard quantities.
What the figures show
How often extra costs arise is published every year by the National Association of Statutory Health Insurance Funds (§ 302(5) SGB V). The eighth report, as of 30 June 2026, evaluates the year 2025:
- Of around 31.9 million supplies of medical aids, 77.69 per cent involved no extra costs.
- For incontinence aids, insured persons paid extra costs in 30.49 per cent of the around 2.65 million cases, 129.10 euros on average. For consumable articles, this amount relates to one year.
- For ostomy articles, it was 1.27 per cent of cases, 45.29 euros on average.
This places incontinence aids among the eight product groups that account for around 96 per cent of all cases with extra costs. The report stresses that the data do not show whether the surcharges were chosen voluntarily in each case. So ask questions if you are told about a surcharge.
What you can do
- Ask for the supply without a surcharge – preferably in writing.
- Ask what you are supposed to pay more for: a surcharge should relate to a feature that you want.
- Ask the fund: it must inform you about its contractual partners and the essential content of the contracts (§ 127(6) SGB V).
- Change supplier: you can choose any contractual partner of your fund (§ 33(6) SGB V).
- Have the quantity adjusted: if the prescribed quantity is not enough, talk to your doctor. How the prescription and approval work is shown in the article Incontinence products on prescription.
Frequently asked questions
Is a surcharge always dubious?
No. If you deliberately want a product with features that go beyond what is necessary, this is exactly what the law provides for. What matters is that you were advised beforehand and knew about the option without a surcharge.
Do extra costs count towards the annual cap?
No. Only the statutory co-payments count towards the annual cap; extra costs for features beyond what is necessary are not included. More on co-payments in the article Higher co-payments from 2027.
May the fund decide which product I get?
The fund owes you sufficient and appropriate supplies, not a particular make. Under the Medical Aids Directive (Hilfsmittel-Richtlinie), the individual product is selected by the supplier together with you, within the framework of your fund’s contracts. If your doctor considers a particular product necessary, it can be prescribed with a justification. What the medical aid number on the prescription means is explained in the article medical aid number.
The product without a surcharge does not suit me – what now?
Then it does not serve its purpose for you, and the fund must provide you with another suitable supply. Ask your doctor to confirm why the product is not suitable, and submit this to your fund. If it refuses, you can lodge an objection.
How PharmaCare helps
PharmaCare works independently of any manufacturer and supplies products from all well-known manufacturers; you will find around 4,000 items in our product search (in German). We have over 400 contracts with statutory and private insurers, advise you on suitable products and arrange approval with your health insurance fund.
You can reach our qualified specialists free of charge, Monday to Friday from 8 am to 5 pm, also via WhatsApp and Signal.
0800 74 222 73WhatsAppSignalSources
- SGB V: § 12 – Principle of economic efficiency, § 33 – Medical aids, § 127 – Contracts, duty to advise, § 302 – Report on extra costs, Federal Ministry of Justice (in German)
- Eighth report on the development of extra costs in the supply of medical aids, reporting period 2025, National Association of Statutory Health Insurance Funds, as of 30 June 2026 (in German)
- List of medical aids, product group 15 “Incontinence aids”, National Association of Statutory Health Insurance Funds, published on 30 January 2025 (in German)
- S2k guideline “Management and performance of intermittent catheterisation (IC) in neurogenic dysfunction of the lower urinary tract”, AWMF register 043-048, update 3.0, February 2026 (in German)
- Medical Aids Directive (§ 7), Federal Joint Committee (in German)
- Annual cap (Belastungsgrenze), Federal Ministry of Health, and Co-payments and exemption from co-payments, gesund.bund.de (in German)
Note: This article gives a general overview and does not replace medical or legal advice. Your health insurance fund or long-term care insurance decides on your entitlement. The text was written with the help of artificial intelligence; all information has been checked against the sources listed. As of: 24 September 2026.